I Tried 35 Pairs Of Fall Birkenstocks: These 7 Are The Best

0

Since Birkenstocks are my go-to comfort shoes (pretty much ANY time of the year), I tried 35 fall Birkenstock styles (yes, 35!) and narrowed them down to my seven favorites.

Spoiler alert: I LOVE this sleek minimalist style (been wearing them on repeat); the brand-new fall colorways in our beloved Boston Rivets are total winners (go ahead…let’s hear the oooooohs + ahhhhhs); and pretty much EVERY fall Birkenstock style is now available in the most gorgeous dark Carafe brown color (including my go-to slip-on Buckleys…yessss!)

Three fall Birkenstock clogs in dark Carafe brown: the Loma, Boston Rivet, and braided Buckley

left | middle | right

Birkenstocks are always by my door, ready to slip on… that molded footbed makes my feet oh-so-happy. So it’s always a surprise when I hear people ask: I love Birkenstocks for summer, but do they work for fall?

The answer is yes… absolutely, yes, yes, yes! Birkenstocks are perfect for fall. Between shearling-lined styles, classic leather clogs (worn with or without socks), and slip-on loafer-inspired designs, there are tons of cute and comfortable fall Birkenstocks to choose from these days.

I recently covered the 2026 fall Birkenstock trends, and I’ve tried an enormous range of fall styles to narrow it down to this review of the 7 best. Of course “best” means different things to different people (please share your own Birk favorites in the comments!), but below you’ll find reviews of my top 7 picks with photos, pros, cons, fit notes, and all the details.

The 7 Best Fall Birkenstocks For 2026

Best Birkenstock Clogs & Shearling Styles For Fall 2026, Reviewed

Of the 35 pairs of fall Birkenstocks I’ve tried, these 7 are my favorites. Many of the Birkenstock styles below I’ve tested, worn, and loved previous years as well, but now they are available in new exciting fall colorways or have new luxe detailing. Below you’ll find reviews of each Birkenstock style with close-up photos, outfit selfies, pros, cons, fit notes, as well as material, footbed, and sole details.

1. Birkenstock Loma Clog Review

Close-up of carafe dark brown suede Birkenstock Loma clog worn on foot

Where To Buy: Birkenstock | Staud

PRICE:  $160
COLORS:  Carafe (shown); Khaki; Charcoal; Thyme; Cork; Dark Tea; Oyster; & Pepper
MATERIAL: Suede leather upper
FOOTBED & SOLE: Suede leather insole; contoured supportive cork footbed; EVA outsole
FIT: TTS. Velcro top strap easy to use for adjusting fit. Available in wide and medium widths. I typically wear a 7-7.5 in shoes. I wear a 37 medium in Birk sandals, but I like the roomier fit of the 38 medium for Birkenstock fall clogs. Note that “narrow/medium” width for Birkenstock is width A/B and “regular/wide” is width C/D.

Close-up side view of carafe dark brown suede Birkenstock Loma clog worn on foot and shown styled in fall outfit with baggy jeans and sweater

Where To Buy: Birkenstock | Staud
denim (27) | sweater (m) | bag

PROS: I LOVE the minimalist chic look of the Loma style; interesting shape and lines, but with clean understated vibes; wrap suede strap adds a luxe look; works well with or without socks; velcro top strap makes it quick and easy to adjust fit (especially when going back and forth between socks/no socks); soft suede on the inside of the shoe’s upper if your feet are sensitive to harder leathers; plenty of room for socks with the wide toebox; gorgeous new fall colorways.

CONS: Some people don’t like velcro straps and prefer buckles; I wish they came in a shearling-lined version.

Carafe dark brown suede Birkenstock Loma clogs styled with wide-leg jeans and leggings and socks.

Where To Buy: Birkenstock | Staud
denim (29) | tank (xs) | bag | sim leggings | hoodie (m) | sim vest


2. Birkenstock Buckley Clog Review

Close-up of tobacco brown leather Birkenstock Buckley clogs worn on foot

Where To Buy: Zappos | DSW | Bloomies | Birkenstock
Shearling-Lined: Zappos | DSW | Birkenstock

PRICE: $155 – $175
COLORS: Tobacco Brown (shown above); Carafe (shown below); Black; Cognac; Beige; Taupe; Navy; Faded Purple; Wheat Brown; Tea; Gray; & White
MATERIAL: Upper available in suede leather (shown below); oiled leather (shown above); and nubuck leather
FOOTBED & SOLE: Suede leather and shearling available for insole; contoured supportive cork footbed; EVA outsole
FIT: TTS. Buckled top strap is adjustable. Available in wide and medium widths. I typically wear a 7-7.5 in shoes. I wear a 37 medium in Birk sandals, but like the roomier fit of the 38 medium for Birkenstock fall clogs. Note that “narrow/medium” width for Birkenstock is width A/B and “regular/wide” is width C/D.

Close-up of tobacco brown leather Birkenstock Buckley clogs worn on foot and styled for fall outfit with baggy jeans and sweater

Where To Buy: Zappos | DSW | Bloomies | Birkenstock
Shearling-Lined: Zappos | DSW | Birkenstock
denim (27) | sweater (m) | bag

PROS: I’ve worn variations of the Birkenstock Buckley Clog for years, and they’re still one of my most-worn fall Birkenstocks; classic moccasin-inspired styling; similar look to the popular Birkenstock Naples, but with a slightly more casual vibe; not as bulky/wide-looking as the Birkenstock Bostons; elastic on the inside upper allows for more give (compared to the leather Bostons) while walking; now available with braided strap detail (shown on me in the dark carafe brown); Buckley style is available in shearling-lined (which I LOVE); I have owned multiple pairs of the shearling-lined Buckleys (they’re INCREDIBLY soft and cozy), but see note below.

CONS: With thick socks, I don’t love this style as much as I like the Birkenstock Loma Clogs (the proportions seem off to me compared to the wider-looking Lomas or Bostons that can handle a bulkier thicker sock); if you choose the shearling-lined, the lining does thin with wear and develops worn patches (doesn’t bother me and I continue wearing, but good to know when considering); the oiled leather is gorgeous and elevated, but stiffer out of the box than the suede.

Tobacco brown leather Birkenstock Buckley clogs styled with wide-leg jeans and leggings and socks.

Where To Buy: Zappos | DSW | Bloomies | Birkenstock
Shearling-Lined: Zappos | DSW | Birkenstock
denim (29) | tank (xs) | bag | sim leggings | hoodie (m) | sim vest


3. Birkenstock Boston Rivet Clogs Review

Close-up of dark brown Carafe color suede Birkenstock Boston Rivets clogs worn on foot

Where To Buy: Anthro | Shopbop | Zappos | Birkenstock

PRICE: $175
COLORS: Carafe (shown above); Taupe (shown below); Black; Stone Blue; Pepper; & Charcoal
MATERIAL: Upper suede leather with metal rivets
FOOTBED & SOLE: Suede leather insole; contoured supportive cork footbed; EVA outsole
FIT: TTS. Buckled top strap is adjustable. Available in wide and medium widths. I typically wear a 7-7.5 in shoes. I wear a 37 medium in Birk sandals, but like the roomier fit of the 38 medium for Birkenstock fall clogs. Note that “narrow/medium” width for Birkenstock is width A/B and “regular/wide” is width C/D.

Close-up of dark brown Carafe color suede Birkenstock Boston Rivets clogs worn on foot and styled with baggy jeans

Where To Buy: Anthro | Shopbop | Zappos | Birkenstock
denim (27) | sweater (m) | bag

PROS: Statement studded detailing is a modern edgy-ish update to the iconic Birkenstock Boston; soft suede on the top of shoe’s upper if your feet are sensitive to harder leathers; expanded fall colorways this year; metal rivets give this style more personality than the classic Birkenstock Bostons; plenty of room for socks with the wide toebox.

CONS: Rivets are modern and stylish, but they don’t show up as much on the lighter colors; I wish these were available with shearling lining option.

Dark brown Carafe color suede Birkenstock Boston Rivets clogs styled with wide-leg jeans outfit and leggings and socks.

Where To Buy: Anthro | Shopbop | Zappos | Birkenstock
denim (29) | tank (xs) | bag | sim leggings | hoodie (m) | sim vest


4. Birkenstock Papillio Boston Chunky Clogs Review

Close-up of dark tea suede Birkenstock Boston Chunky clogs worn on foot

Where To Buy: Zappos | DSW | Free People | Birkenstock
Shearling-Lined: Birkenstock

PRICE: $155
COLORS: Tea (shown); Mocha; Pink; Taupe; Black; Sand; Gray; Blue; Sage; Oyster; & Pepper
MATERIAL: Suede leather upper
FOOTBED & SOLE: Suede leather and shearling available for insole; contoured supportive cork footbed; platform 1.25″ EVA outsole
FIT: TTS. Buckled top strap is adjustable. Available in wide and medium widths. I typically wear a 7-7.5 in shoes. I wear a 37 medium in Birk sandals, but I like the roomier fit of the 38 medium for Birkenstock fall clogs. Note that “narrow/medium” width for Birkenstock is actually width A/B and “regular/wide” is width C/D.

Close-up of dark tea suede Birkenstock Boston Chunky clogs worn on foot and styled with baggy jeans and sweater

Where To Buy: DSW | Zappos | Free People | Birkenstock
Shearling-Lined: Birkenstock
denim (27) | sweater (m) | bag

PROS: Bold and edgier lug-sole look when compared to the traditional Birk soles; firm supportive feel despite “squishy platform look”; I love the dark brown (tea) with contrasting black sole; adds nice height for full-length jeans/pants.

CONS: Heavier and clunkier feel and weight than regular Birkenstock Boston Clogs; they also have a big and chunky look that feels too bulky for some people.

Dark tea suede Birkenstock Boston Chunky clogs styled with wide-leg jeans outfit and leggings and socks

Where To Buy: DSW | Zappos | Free People | Birkenstock
Shearling-Lined: Birkenstock
denim (29) | tank (xs) | bag | sim leggings | hoodie (m) | sim vest


5. Birkenstock Arizona Shearling Big Buckle Sandal Review

Close-up of cognac tan leather Birkenstock Shearling-Lined Arizona sandals worn on foot

Where To Buy: Birkenstock | Bloomies | Zappos

PRICE: $196
COLORS: Cognac (shown); Black; Lavender; Thyme; Blue; & Habana
MATERIAL: Upper available in oiled leather (shown) and suede
FOOTBED & SOLE:
Shearling insole; contoured supportive cork footbed; EVA outsole
FIT: Similar to my other Arizona sandals, I size down in this style: I’m typically a 7 in sandals/7.5 in sneakers, and I wear a 37 “medium/narrow” in Arizonas. Note that “medium/narrow” width for Birkenstock is actually width A/B. Available also in “wide/regular (C/D)”.

Fall Outfit with Birkenstock Arizona Shearling Big Buckle styled with wide-leg barrel jeans and brown cashmere sweater.

Where To Buy: Birkenstock | Bloomies | Zappos
denim (27) | sweater (m) | bag

PROS: A fantastic option for a cute fall transition sandal or a cozy and supportive shoe to wear around the house in the winter (I’ve worn this style for both purposes); the shearling lining is soft and keeps my feet a perfect temperature on cool fall days (while showing off a cute fall pedicure!); my feet sometimes get overheated in full shearling shoes, so these are perfect temperature-wise for fall (or winter around the house); comfortable and supportive (per usual with Birks); see note below about shearling.

CONS: The shearling lining (like I’ve experienced with all shearling-lined Birks) does thin with wear and after a while creates some bare patches in the lining (I don’t mind this, but good to know before making a purchase); people totally question me on the street when I’m wearing sandals in late fall (but they really do keep my feet plenty warm).

Fall wide-leg jeans outfit with Birkenstock Arizona Shearling Sandals  and workout outfit with socks and leggings.

Where To Buy: Birkenstock | Bloomies | Zappos
denim (29) | tank (xs) | bag | sim leggings | hoodie (m) | sim vest


6. Birkenstock Boston Big Buckle Clog Review

Close-up of taupe leather Birkenstock Boston Big Buckle Clog worn on foot

Where To Buy: Zappos | Anthro | Bloomies | Birkenstock
Shearling-Lined: Birkenstock

PRICE: $180
COLORS: Sandcastle (shown); Carafe; Pepper; Faded Purple; & Mink
MATERIAL: Upper nubuck leather
FOOTBED & SOLE:
Suede leather insole; contoured supportive cork footbed; EVA outsole
FIT: TTS. Buckled top strap is adjustable. Available in wide and medium widths. I typically wear a 7-7.5 in shoes. I wear a 37 medium in Birk sandals, but I like the roomier fit of the 38 medium for Birkenstock fall clogs. Note that “narrow/medium” width for Birkenstock is actually width A/B.

Close-up of taupe leather Birkenstock Boston Big Buckle Clog worn on foot and styled with wide-leg barrel jeans and brown cashmere sweater.

Where To Buy: Zappos | Anthro | Bloomies | Birkenstock
Shearling-Lined: Birkenstock
denim (27) | sweater (m) | bag

PROS: Elevated and chic take on the classic Birkenstock Boston clogs; same Birkenstock Boston clog feel, but with some interest and a sophisticated touch; the sturdy nubuck leather is REALLY pretty and helps create a more polished Birk look; the nubuck leather holds its shape better than the more flexible suede Birkenstocks; new rich fall colorways available in this style.  

CONS: Leather is smooth and very pretty, but gets scuffed easily; the upper nubuck leather version is sturdier and holds its shape better than suede, but is also stiffer (if your feet are sensitive to that); if you choose the shearling-lined version, note that the shearling lining on all Birkenstocks wears down and creates thin/bare patches on the footbed (I personally don’t mind this, but something to consider).

Fall Birkenstock Boston Big Buckle Clogs styled with leggings and socks and wide-leg jeans

Where To Buy: Zappos | Anthro | Bloomies | Birkenstock
Shearling-Lined: Birkenstock
denim (29) | tank (xs) | bag | sim leggings | hoodie (m) | sim vest


7. Birkenstock Naples Loafer Clog Review

Close-up of navy blue suede Birkenstock Naples clog worn on foot

Where To Buy: Zappos | Anthro | Shopbop | Birkenstock

PRICE: $165
COLORS: Midnight Blue (shown above); Cork Brown (shown below); Habana; Black; Tobacco Brown; Concrete; Taupe; Clay; Carafe; Pepper; Dark Tea; & Charcoal
MATERIAL: Upper available in suede leather, oiled leather, and mixed leather
FOOTBED & SOLE:
Suede leather insole; contoured cork footbed; EVA outsole
FIT: TTS. No adjustable top straps or buckles. Available in wide and medium widths. I typically wear a 7-7.5 in shoes. I wear a 37 medium in Birk sandals, but like the roomier fit of the 38 medium for Birkenstock fall clogs. Note that “narrow/medium” width for Birkenstock is width A/B and “regular/wide” is width C/D.

Close-up of navy blue suede Birkenstock Naples clog worn on foot and cork brown BIrkenstock Naples with baggy jeans

Where To Buy: Zappos | Anthro | Shopbop | Birkenstock
denim (27) | sweater (m) | bag

PROS: Polished and sleek loafer-inspired style; luxe looking; the wrapped leather design (no cork showing) has a very elevated look; this style is more widely available for fall 2026 (rather than in 2025 when it was sold out at most retailers); more colorways than previously offered.

CONS: No adjustable top strap or buckle; not available in shearling-lined (similar Buckleys are available with shearling lining).

Navy blue and cork brown suede Birkenstock Naples clogs styled with wide-leg jeans and leggings and socks outfits.

Where To Buy: Zappos | Anthro | Shopbop | Birkenstock
denim (29) | tank (xs) | bag | sim leggings | hoodie (m) | sim vest


Fall Birkenstock FAQ: Sizing, Widths & Shearling

Photo showing multiple fall Birkenstock clog styles together in a row

Birkenstock sizing and shearling-lined Birkenstocks are the two things I get asked about the most when it comes to fall Birkenstocks. Since they can be tricky (and sometimes confusing), I pulled together answers to the questions that come up again and again.

Q. Do shearling-lined Birkenstocks wear down over time?

A. Yes. The shearling thins and can develop bare patches with wear. It doesn’t bother me personally, but it’s good to know before you buy.

Q. What does worn shearling look like?

A. In the two sets of photos below, the pair on the left is brand new, while the pair on the right has been through a couple of well-loved seasons. You can see how the lining thins, but they’re still totally wearable.

Q. Are shearling-lined Birkenstocks too warm for fall?

A. Not for me. They’re cozy on cool days but not overly hot since parts of your foot stay uncovered. That balance makes them great for crisp fall weather without feeling stuffy.

Q. How do Birkenstock sizing and widths work?

A. Birkenstock widths can be confusing: Narrow/Medium (A–B) and Regular/Wide (C–D). An easy way to tell them apart is that A-B has a solid foot icon stamped inside, while C-D shows just the outline.

Q. Why do different retailers label Birkenstock widths differently?

A. Ugh. It’s confusing. Zappos calls A–B “narrow,” Nordstrom lists it as “B,” and some retailers don’t label widths at all. A–B is usually the default most retailers stock.

Q. Which width should I choose?

A. Most people do fine in Narrow/Medium (A–B). If you usually wear wide-sized shoes, like extra room, or plan to wear REALLY thick socks, consider the Regular/Wide (C–D). I have wide-ish feet, though, and still wear Narrow/Medium (A-B).

Q. Where can I find the best Birkenstock sizing and width info?

A. Birkenstock’s official website has the most complete sizing and width guide, along with the widest range of options in both Narrow/Medium and Regular/Wide sizing.

Birkenstock Buckley vs. Boston vs. Naples: which should I get?

Boston is the widest and roomiest for thick socks, Buckley is slimmer and more moccasin-like with an elastic inner that gives as you walk, Naples is the dressiest with wrapped leather and no adjustable strap.

Are Birkenstock clogs still in style for fall 2026?

Yes! If anything, the clog lineup is bigger than ever. Birkenstock expanded fall colorways across nearly every style (hello, Carafe brown), added luxe details like rivets and big buckles, and brought back the Naples in more colors after it sold out everywhere last fall. What’s shifted is the styling: the look has moved away from chunky-with-everything toward sleeker, loafer-inspired shapes like the Loma and Naples, worn with straight or wide-leg denim rather than leggings. I break down the specific shapes, colors, and details trending this season in my fall 2026 Birkenstock trends post.


Where To Find Birkenstocks On Sale Or Discounted

Birkenstocks are high-quality comfort shoes that I think are absolutely worth the cost (especially since I wear them almost daily). That said, it’s always fun to find them on sale. While big retailers sometimes mark down older colors or past-season styles, here are all the spots I’ve found the most reliable for scoring discounted or secondhand Birkenstocks in good condition:

  • Birkenstock Last Chance (on Birkenstock’s official site)
  • Zappos (marked down seasonal colors/styles)
  • Nordstrom Rack (often has past-season colors and styles)
  • DSW (marked down seasonal colors/styles)
  • eBay (great for secondhand or hard-to-find styles)
  • TheRealReal (secondhand, but often in excellent condition)
  • ThredUp (secondhand and often for less than other secondhand retailers)

And…there you have it! Your questions answered about fall Birkenstocks as well as my very top picks for the best fall Birkenstocks of 2026 — the Loma, Buckley, Boston Rivets, Arizona Shearling, Boston Big Buckle, Boston Chunky, and the Naples. Whether you’re drawn to timeless clog styles, cozy shearling sandals, an edgy Birkenstock refresh, or a sophisticated statement buckle, there’s plenty to choose from this season for sure.

Feel free to shout out your own personal fav Birks for fall! Always love hearing from you all.

-Linzi

I’m currently donating to Democracy Forward, an organization doing important legal work to protect democracy. Want to join me?


More TME Birkenstock Reviews, Styling, & Trend Posts

LEAVE A REPLY