Hey hey…back with an early Fall version of our monthly group post. Hope everyone is getting back into the swing of the school year and that it’s going well. When I was considering what would be fun to cover next, sweaters came to mind. There’s nothing better than a cozy sweater moment this time of year.
Those crisp mornings and evenings are right around the corner and if you need some inspiration for a new sweater in your life, we got you. I think this was a pretty easy lift for the team as we all could have made multiple suggestions. If you want to check out some of our favorite overall sweater recs from over the years, here’s a little list below:
- Quince Cashmere Vs. Jenni Kayne
- Best Cashmere Sweaters: Our Yearly Guide
- What To Buy (& Skip) At Quince
Or keep scrolling for our current top sweater picks for early Fall!
The Best Sweaters For Early Fall 2025 (Team Favorites): Quince, Jenni Kayne, Free People, Gap Factory + More
Because the anticipation of the coming season is sooo fun (whether you like PSLs or not), slipping into long sleeves for the first cool temps is just…a whole vibe. And we’re all here for it because it wasn’t hard to figure out our favorite early fall picks. Most of us are loving a nice thick cotton for this time of year and we have some real gems below for you. We’ll also be back with more late fall + wintery suggestions later, but for now…here’s what we’re putting on now.
Shana’s Favorite Sweater For Early Fall

sweater (s)
Why I Love This: J.Crew brought back their iconic roll neck sweater – a piece I remember fondly from high school – but better. The body is a little boxier, and the shoulders have been reconfigured for a drapier, slouchier look. It’s fantastic. It’s 100% cotton, and reminds me of La Ligne or Jenni Kayne, but at a much lower price point. My only word of caution is that the colors aren’t all accurately represented on the website. The pink striped is brighter (think: peptol) in person, and the navy is so dark it’s almost black.
Sizing: I tried on the XS, S and M. The biggest difference between the sizes were the arm sleeve length and the body length. The XS fit a little more like a traditional sweater, and the Medium was a little longer/slouchier. I ended up sticking with my usual size to get that perfectly slouchy, slightly oversized look. Highly recommend this piece – it’s a good one.
Outfit Details: sweater (s) | shorts | sandals | bag | sunglasses | J.Crew Model’s jeans (haha I’m eyeing them up, too)
Scotti’s Favorite Sweater For Early Fall
sweater (small, more colors here)
Why I Love This: Not all sweaters work for summer → fall, but this one nails it. 100% cotton so I’m not sweating, cozy cable-knit texture, and a chill faded wash that makes it feel effortless. And since fall takes its sweet time showing up here in Chicago (unlike Marquette), I’m happily soaking up every extra week of “light sweater weather.”
Outfit Details: sweater (s) | shorts (28) | similar slides
Where To Buy: Nordstrom | Free People | Bloomingdale’s | Backcountry (40% off black!)
Laura’s Favorite Sweater For Early Fall
Sweater (S)
Why I Love This: First off, it’s under $50.It’s also made of incredibly high quality cotton in a fisherman rib (which I not only love the texture of but will last a long time.) And for those of us with slightly shorter torsos, this sweater hits at exactly the right spot…not too long, not too short. I wound up sizing down on this because I’ve realized for thicker/heavier items I don’t want them too oversized, but if you want a little more boxy, stick true to size. This is woven really well, but cotton will still stretch just a bit with wear, too.
Outfit Details: Sweater (S) | Pants (M) | Similar Slides
Where To Buy: Quince
Emily’s Favorite Sweater For Early Fall
Sweater (S)
Why I Love This: This Montecito Sweater from Frank & Eileen is the new It Sweater. Like, it’s Jenni Kayne, eat your heart out GOOD. It’s bonkers pricey, but if sustainability and ethical sourcing are high on your list of priorities, this is where you’ll want to invest your hard-earned dollars. The stitching is absurdly perfect – it’s a piece of art – and the cool inverted seams add so much interest. It’s one-hundred percent Italian-dyed, Egyptian cotton composition, and the colors are all super saturated and positively gorgeous. Fit is decadently oversized. (This is a small, and it fits more like a medium. If you like more of a traditional fit, I’d size down one.)
Outfit Details: Sweater (S) | Collared Popover (S) | Shorts (S)
Where to Buy: Frank & Eileen | Select colors at Nordstrom
Linzi’s Favorite Sweater For Early Fall
Why I Love: This Frank & Eileen Monterey Sweater is made with the most wildly soft and luxurious cotton EVER (pure Italian yarn, knitted in California, and it DOESN’T pill!). The attention to detail is impeccable – the roll neck, drape, and exposed seams running down the arms are like no other sweater I’ve ever worn. And yes….it is unfortunately annoyingly very expensive. But… the quality is beyond outstanding, and the shape and style is classic so it will have a place in my closet forever. I sometimes wear it untucked and sometimes do the little half tuck thing in the front. If you want something shorter and boxier…I also adore my luxe cotton striped Jenni Kayne (but sizing is limited).
Outfit Details: sweater (s) | pants (8) | bag
Where To Buy: Frank & Eileen | Select colors at Nordstrom
Abby’s Favorite Sweater For Early Fall
Sweater (M)
Why I Love This: So apparently Sonderhaus wanted to create the perfect “chunky-while-still-being-flattering” sweater and their Gwendolyn sweater is IT. It’s 100% organic cotton, has perfect sleeves for a sleeve bunch, is a great medium weight (I wear it in every season) and the fitted neckline keeps it looking not too loose nor chunky. It’s actually unreal – I have it in cotton in “butter” and wool in “cobalt”.
Outfit Details: sweater (M) | dress (M) | sneakers
Where To Buy: Sonderhaus
Jess’ Favorite Sweater For Early Fall
Why I Love This: I have TME’s Amy to thank for bringing this sweater into my life. She pointed it out during our meeting and I bought it SO fast. I love this ‘twist of lime’ shade of green that is the perfect mix between a bright green and a warm shade that makes it perfect for the end of summer, and on into fall. One of the things I love most about this sweater besides the color and the styling, is the price! It’s currently on sale too and under $50 at Gap Factory!
Outfit Details: Sweater (S) | Jeans (27)
Where to Buy: Gap Factory
xo,
Laura + Team TME













Fabulous posting. Excellent choices of sweaters!! Thank you.
I want the F & E sweater but it’s insanely expensive….