I wandered back into Nordstroms the other day, intent on trying a few pairs of shoes. I had a few questions in mind:
1. Were the Weitzman OTK boots as fab as I had hoped?
2. Did any other ankle boot beat out the Weiztman perfection booties?
3. Was there something amazing I had previously overlooked?
No, Not Really, and YES. Keep reading for details about my Nordstrom Anniversary sale picks….
Battle of Over-The-Knee
The Weiztman Hilos
The biggest disappointment was the Weiztman Hilo Over-The-Knee boots. Now, this might just be a personal problem between the Hilos and me – I’m awfully short, and these bad boys come up so high that the result is more fishing waders than sleek sophistication, but they had one major design flaw I’m having trouble overlooking:
Pirate boots. They look, ever-so-slightly, like pirate boots.
Again, this might be because of my height, but if you compare the Weiztman Hilo boots to the much-beloved Weitzman Lowland boots (not on sale), you find that the Lowland boots not only have a closure at the top (which really, really helps with the pirate situation), but the shaft of the boot is made out of a combination of leather and synthetic material, making the boot easy to pull on/off, comfortable to wear and comfortable to sit down.
The Hilo boots, however, have a shaft of 100% leather and suede, and are a little cumbersome behind the knee, as well as harder to pull on/off. I also fear that with time, these boots will slouch lower and lower as they stretch out.
If you are dying for a pair of Lowland-like boots, I would recommend trying the Charles David Gunter Boots (only $109 on sale!). They have all of the features I look for in OTK boots: a sleek silhouette, a simple top closure, and some synthetic material in the shaft.
Steve Madden’s Gleemer Boot
The Steve Madden Gleemer Boots are good – surprisingly so, especially for the $99 sale price. Comfy, easy to get on/off, easy to walk in. I was surprised to see a 4″ heel listed. They do feel high, but not that high. They have a lace-up back at the top of the boot to keep them sleek and snug – necessary, but I don’t quite love how it looks. Again, it might just be too much for my short self.
This, BTW, is how you get the really high OTK boots on and off (and why you want some synthetic material in the shaft):
Sam Edelman’s Kent Boot
The clear winner was a boot that I cannot find online. I’ve called back to the Cherry Hill Nordstroms twice, to verify that these boots are, in fact, part of the sale, and they insist, YES. Yes they are. But there’s no mention of these boots on Nordstrom.com, nor any other place on the Internets. The mysterious Sam Edelman Kent boots (on sale for something like $129) are a dead-ringer for Weitzman’s Highland boots. In fact, I own a pair of Highlands, and I’d be hard pressed to tell the difference!
I’ll reach out to my Nordstrom contacts to see if they can help me solve The Case of The Missing Boots. In the meantime, if you are a Philly local, get yourself over to Cherry Hill and snap them up before they’re gone.
Can anything beat out the sheer perfection of the Weitzman Perfection Ankle Boots? They run small and a bit narrow, but are otherwise, like the name implies, perfect:
Sam Edelman Reyes Bootie
Love it! The Sam Edelman Reyes Bootie is nice and tall, narrow through the shaft, with a solid, walkable heel. My only beef is that the upper is a bit stiff, especially compared to the sock-like top of the Weitzman’s.
Louise Et Cie’s Shayna Bootie
I had to try on the Shayna Booties. (Fun fact: my name is spelled differently, but is actually pronounced ‘Shayna’.) In any case, these are seriously cute boots that meet my criteria for a modern ankle boot: a higher shaft, and narrow around the ankle. They’re also comfortable to walk in.
My Two Favs – Cut-Out Booties
So I went in expecting to just nerd out on the OTK and modern ankle boots, and found myself totally distracted by the cut-out booties! They’re seriously comfortable – even without socks – and look shockingly cool.
Lucky Brand Bashina Perforated Boot
The Lucky Bashina Boot is the one I went home with. I’m obsessed. It’s so comfy (padded footbed, soft leather upper) and makes jeans and cut-offs instantly cooler. A total and complete WIN, especially for under $100. You’ll be seeing a ton of this one….
….which is a good thing because GAH! I only have THIS picture of the boot! (Same one I put on Instagram, @shanachristine). Sorry gang – clearly I was excited and distracted. I’ll throw another up on Instagram soon.
Vince Camuto Katleen Peep Toe Bootie
The Vince Camuto Katleen is the boot I left behind, but can’t stop thinking about. So cute, and while the heel is high, the footbed is VERY padded, and the heel so chunky, that I do think I could actually wear these on date nights and still walk around. I mean there are Uber shoes and there are walking shoes and these….might….be….walking shoes?
Also, I couldn’t decide between black and “Prarie Dust Suede” and then my brain was like TOO MANY DECISIONS and I walked.
My kids, in the chair next to me happily playing video games, were all like, “No Mom, why don’t you keep trying stuff on?” Electronic babysitting at it’s finest.
GAH! I love that asymmetrical detail!
Vince Camuto Peera Cut-Out Booties
The Vince Camuto Peera boots are so freaking cute. My only beef is that they weren’t AS COMFORTABLE without socks as the Lucky Brand boots. But I’ll admit, I’m getting really, really picky at this point. There’s only so much time one can spend taking pictures of one’s feet before THE CRAZY COMES.
Here Cometh The Crazy
Totally unlike me, but I love these red Hunters. Clearly, a midlife crisis is on the horizon. (Mike, I just need more…COLOR in my life!! #hahano)
Vince Preston sneakers: Always a safe bet. Stupidly comfy, and so sleek. The lighting was really tough to “shoot” in (haha – so profesh with my iPhone), but Vince is straddling the line of not-obnoxious metallics really, really well. Also in a black linen, which is soverycool.
Someone tell me which color to get in the Vince Camuto cut-out heels. I’m leaning towards “Prairie Dust Suede”, but I might get more use out of the black. Also, the jeans are part of the sale (AG skinnies that I hacked off – but need to hack off another inch or so), and the top is this Free People one.
I’m still obsessed with the Kate Spade moc boots (from this article), but they are selling out pretty quickly. Typically, Nordstrom will save some inventory for the public sale, so it’s worth checking back. And the floral Nikes (from the same article) are perfect for those of you who don’t typically wear sneakers. (Scotti, I’m talking to you.) They’re just so pretty!
Ok – now I’ve got to go pack. I’m taking the boys to Michigan for a week or so to visit family. Expect my makeup to suddenly be on-point because Scotti. And baby Greenlea is now talking up a storm, and it’s so hysterically cute I can’t. even. stand it.
ps. If anyone wants to send in pics – especially of shoes/boots that might not be in-store, we’d love to share them! email@example.com
Definitely the Prairie Dust. The black is ok and that’s it. Ok. The Prairie Dust is hot.
What color are the Lucky shoes? I see 2 shades of brown on the website. Also, I am 7-7.5 in shoes? Which size would you go with? Thanks in advance!
I had the same questions. 🙂
So you know when you’re reading a scifi/fantasy book and you get to the end and it turns out there’s a pronunciation guide and you’ve been mentally mispronouncing the main character’s name the whole book? Yeah, that.
Also, I like the black better on you because the contrast with your skin tone makes the asymmetric detail pop. I missed it on the prairie dust ones.
Bahahaha. Allison, you read my thoughts on the name thing!
Hi, love your reviews. What jeans are you wearing? I think I need those!
And now my life isn’t complete without those cut-out booties…*sigh*. #shanaismakingmebroke
Prairie dust suede. All day long.
I’m loving those Bashina booties! Question: are they something we’ll need to put away once it gets a little chilly in Philly? Or throw on a pair of socks and we’re good? I can’t tell from pics online…
I wore the heck out of my lucky booties last winter, just SO comfy…perfect low heel, look great with anything, easy to throw on and great price! To balance the four nas orders I placed this week!!
Well shoot… I had those Lucky boots on my list to buy, then instead ordered the Splendid booties that were on sale at Amazon… I guess I’m returning the amazon booties because I am hoping for something super comfy? I can’t believe how much energy I’m wasting thinking about this. LOL.
So- the Charles David boots? Or the Blondo boots in your Anni store? I like them both- but liked that the Blondo pair are waterproof. If you had to pick, which ones???
Your name!!!!! 😀
I ordered the blondo wedges, Vince booties and Aquatalia to try at home I’m hoping I will narrow it down once I try them on
I adore those moc boots and wish I had the budget for them this year! Awesome!
Thank you, this post was SUPER helpful… actually convinced me not to buy the Peera booties based on how they look on. Bu now I love the Lucky ones! Yay! 🙂
Also – not a fan of any of the thigh-high boots. Ick.
Prarie Dust! Love them and that color!
Just found you on Instagram, yay! First off thanks for taking all these pictures, beyond thorough and super helpful. Was wondering for sizing reference how tall you were?
For the booties I like the Prarie Dust color.
And now you’ve got me thinking about the Rebecca Minkoff backpack. I will dream about it tonight.
Ack! No Bashinas in my size 🙁
All those heels….my feet hurt just looking at them!
Was SO hoping you would have tried and reviewed the AGL “Ella Block Hell Bootie”! I know you can’t do it all, but they look like a great option for someone looking for a narrower boot shaft under $300.
And by hell I mean heel…
I ordered them in the prarie dust — OBSESSED! I’m also debating those lucky booties or the vince camuto preeera — they’re both SO cute, and I could use a pair in my life but having the same color debate… do I need all the same color?! Brain overwhelmed.
The prarie dust are cutter, but i still am drawn to the Lucky’s. The cut outs are super cute and its a nice height. I have a serious tall boot issue because im short too but i have “big” calves and only once have i found slip on boots that were wide enough and super comfy. My journey for boots continue.
Damn it Shana! I was avoiding the shoe sale for a reason but now I’ve got the Vince metallic sneakers and Lucky boots headed to my house. GIVE ME ALL THE VINCE SNEAKERS! They’re seriously my favorite shoes in the fall and winter!
I see the Lucky boots sold old :-(. Anyone try the Vince Hallie booties?
I don’t have those particular ones but I am a huge fan of Vinve shoes! Totally worth the investment.
They just restocked them!!
I have them and they are super comfortable, not sure they work with a crop jean tho! I love Vince shoes they fit really well.
Prairie Dust Suede! Alas, not in my size…
And I got the Sam Edelman Reyes last year for Christmas, and they are just amazing! And after wearing once or twice, I didn’t notice any stiffness at all…
This has been SO THOROUGH AND HELPFUL. My shopping cart brimmeth over thanks to all of your fabulous suggestions! Question: WHAT jeans are you wearing? Love them, love them, love them.
Hi! Loving these round-ups!! I am on the hunt for a staple flannel shirt, did you happen to see any in the sale that you loved? 🙂
The previous post had a Paige one and Rails has a few in the sale
I also want to buy new sandals but I don’t know what I want for this rainy season. Thank you for your post and I guess I will find some nude sandals, they looks really nice!
Were the Sam Edelman Kent OTK boots true to size? Or did you have to go up a half size?
Insert super sad face — those Lucky boots are sold out in that color. Boooohooo.
The Sam Edelman boots were at my Nordstrom and rang up at $149! Love them! Don’t love the shiny silver toggle, but I’ll fix that!
ahh I’ve been on a hunt for them! Did you feel like they were true to size??
Do you have a side photo of the hunter boots?
Pirate boots. They look, ever-so-slightly, like pirate boots.
Nordstrom Anniversary Sale: The One Where
That is so funny what you mentioned about the mysterious Kent OTK boots because I saw the boots at the store and went home to look for them online to purchase. I wasn’t able to find ANYTHING. So I went back to the store and purchased it and found out the name of the boots are “Kent Black Suede” and still NOTHING online, barely a trace of the boots on ANY website. I wonder if they were taken off the “market” because they are SOO similar to the highland for legal/copyright reasons? It just so strange and odd to me that I cannot find a single thing about these boots. They are absolutely LOVELY and even BETTER than the highlands for a fraction of the price.
I bought the Stuart Weitzman OTK boots and like you found them way too tall, however I am only 5:4 they did however look amazing on my 5:10 daughter so if you have long long legs go for them, if you are shorter in height maybe give them a miss 🙁
Bloomingdales seems to have the Sam Edelman Kent boots online for $130
love your shoes